Just how stable are AI Overviews? If you manage to get your brand mentioned or cited in them, can you take the rest of the month off? Or do you have to fight for ongoing visibility?
To find the answers, our data scientist, Xibeijia Guan, analyzed over 43,000 keywords—each with at least 16 recorded AI Overviews—over the course of a month.
She extracted this data from Brand Radar, our new AI visibility tool that tracks hundreds of millions of prompts and queries across seven different AI assistants.
The results reveal a surprising paradox in how Google’s AI operates—a constant state of change on the surface, but a deep, underlying stability.
Forbes and Fortune showed up consistently between October and November, but the third URL changed.
Initially, a Reddit comment about protein powders took second place, but a month later it was replaced by Fortune’s “best” list, and a new article from NBC on “protein shake safety” entered the third spot.
Here’s one more example for the query “renter’s insurance”—each AI Overview was captured just a week apart.
The first AI Overview returned three citations, but only two of those carried over to the second capture, where a further ten citations joined the list.
It’s clear that AI Overview visibility doesn’t follow the same consistency patterns as traditional search rankings.
Your brand can be cited today, and gone tomorrow.
Further reading
In fact, his hypothesis sparked this whole study…
But the findings disprove this.
Firstly, we’d expect to see far more stability across AI Overview content if some were being cached.
But, as we already know, consecutive AI Overviews showed different content 7 out of 10 times.
Secondly, Xibeijia measured the actual relationship between a keyword’s search volume and its AI Overview change rate, and found a Spearman correlation of -0.014.
A correlation this close to zero indicates there is likely no relationship between the two variables—hugely popular search queries are just as likely to have their AI Overview text change as very niche ones.
So, it’s unlikely Google caches popular AI Overviews—at least based on our data.
Wrapping up
AI Overviews are both dynamic and stable at the same time.
The surface details, like the exact wording, URLs cited, and entities mentioned all switch constantly—but the underlying meaning and the core topics stay the same.
This changes how we can think about AI-generated search results.
They’re not static like traditional search results, but they’re not random either.
While you should expect your brand mentions and citations in AI Overviews to be volatile, there’s still a way to show up consistently.
Rather than focusing on individual prompts or queries, you need to become an authority on the themes associated with your core topics.
You can understand which themes AI ties to your brand using Ahrefs Brand Radar.
Just drop in your brand, and head to the “Topics” report. This will show you which themes individual AI responses ladder up to.
For example, Ahrefs is most closely linked to the topics of “SEO tools” and “SEO software” in AI Overview responses.
Tracking AI visibility over a volume of answers will also help you see past the variance of AI responses.
By focusing on aggregated visibility and AI Share of Voice, you can:
- See if AI consistently ties you to a category—not just if you appeared once.
- Track trends over time—not just snapshots.
- Learn how your brand is positioned against competitors—not just mentioned.
Winning the topic, not the query, is the best way to stay visible—even when AI answers are changing daily.
Similar Posts
15 Ahrefs MCP Use Cases for SEOs & Digital Marketers
With the recent launch of our remote MCP server, anyone can now chat directly with Ahrefs data to get actionable SEO insights. MCP, which stands for Model Context Protocol, is an open standard that companies can use to integrate their external tools and data with compatible AI assistants. Imagine you’ve recently launched a new clothing…
How to Compare Your AI Visibility Against Your Competitors
If a competitor is mentioned more often, cited more frequently, or framed more favorably in AI answers, they win attention and trust before searchers even know you exist. This guide shows you how to run an AI search competitor analysis that reveals: Which brands in your industry dominate AI search today Where your competitors earn visibility,…
£9M Ecommerce Sales: 6 Takeaways From the Success of CarMats.co.uk
In May 2020, during the height of the COVID pandemic, Ash Young started an ecommerce store selling car mats in the UK. His goal was to hit £1M in sales in a year. He hit that target in just 9 months. Today his store has turned over ~£9M. Given that the site’s monthly traffic peaked…
Short Domain Names: A Top Guide to the Benefits of Short URLs & How To Find Them
What can a short domain name do for your business? Are there even any left to choose from? Find out more. Short domain names can pack a punch, so it’s no wonder they’re so popular. Some of the biggest companies in the world use them and with good reason. In this article, we’re going to…
How to Get Customers (There Are Only 4 Ways)
Getting customers is the lifeblood of any business. But search for “how to get customers,” and you’ll find yourself flooded with advice, tips, and tactics. It’s hard to know which one to choose, considering that you have limited resources. Fortunately, most strategies on how to get customers boil down to these four fundamental methods: Find…
My Complete AI Content Process for Ahrefs
Here’s the complete process I use to publish high-quality AI content on the Ahrefs blog. I’ll be honest: there are parts of my job that I don’t like. Writing my 500th article on content gap analysis because we found a new long-tail keyword to target. Listing out the features of 30 free SEO tools for yet…
