How to Track Website Metrics With One Free, Privacy-Friendly Tool

There are plenty of website metrics out there, and just as many tools to track them.

So, to clear up the confusion, I’ll show you the key metrics that really matter, explain how to make sense of them, and show you how to do it all with one free, privacy-friendly tool that’s ready for the AI age.

Ahrefs Webmaster Tools suite. It includes three tools: Web Analytics to track traffic and site performance, Site Explorer to see how your site is doing in search, and Site Audit to check for technical SEO issues.

AWT Suite: 3 tools in one.

I’ll also suggest some other tools you can use if you’re looking for different features or have specific needs.

Google Analytics 4 or Simple Analytics.

Hotjar or Microsoft Clarity for heatmaps and session recordings.

SEO metrics reveal how discoverable your website is and how well it performs in search engines. These numbers directly impact how many people can find your content through Google.

Keyword rankings show which search terms bring people to your site without paid advertising. When someone searches for “how to bake sourdough bread” and finds your recipe, that’s organic traffic driven by your keyword rankings.

To get data on your Keywords in AWT, open the Site Explorer tool and click on the Organic keywords report. You can also set up a filter to track important keywords. In this example, I’ve set the filters to Positions 1-20, and search volume min. 500. This shows me the best-performing target keywords.

Using filters in Organic keywords report.

Referring domain growth measures how many other websites link to yours. When a food blog links to your sourdough recipe or a business publication references your marketing guide, those backlinks signal to search engines that your content is valuable and trustworthy.

Quality matters more than quantity; one link from a respected industry publication is worth more than dozens from low-quality sites.

Get referring domain data by clicking on the Backlink profile tab in Site Explorer’s Overview report.

Backlink profile data in Site Audit.

Branded vs. unbranded traffic. Branded traffic comes from people searching specifically for your company or products (like “ahrefs keywords explorer”). Unbranded traffic comes from people searching for general topics you cover (for example, “keyword research”).

Both are valuable: branded traffic shows you’re building recognition, while unbranded traffic demonstrates your ability to attract new audiences who don’t yet know your brand but are searching for solutions you provide.

While in the overview report, scroll down a bit, and you’ll see the branded vs non-branded chart.

Branded vs. non-branded organic traffic chart.

Ahrefs Webmaster Tools also monitors when AI tools cite your content as source material in their responses, even when users don’t click through to visit your website.

Citation visibility shows your content’s influence beyond traditional metrics. When ChatGPT or Perplexity references your research, quotes your expertise, or uses your content to answer questions, that’s valuable brand exposure and authority building, even if it doesn’t generate immediate traffic.

You can find your AI citation count with a breakdown of sources in the Overview report.

AI citations data in Site Explorer.

Tip

If you also want to know when and how your brand was mentioned by ChatGPT, Perplexity, Copilot, and AI Overviews, take a look at Ahrefs’ Brand Radar. It’s got data on your competitors, too.

Ahrefs Brand Radar - competitive analysis.

Core Web Vitals measure the technical user experience of your site: how fast pages load, how quickly they respond to clicks, and how stable the layout is while loading. These metrics can affect both your search rankings and user satisfaction. Nobody likes waiting for a slow, clunky website to load.

To enable Core Web Vitals, you first need to get a free CWV API key and provide it in Site Audit’s Settings (here’s how to do that step by step). Next, click on the performance report in Site Audit. You’ll see the number of pages with poor scores—the goal is to improve them to reach a “Good” grade (we’ve got a guide on that, too)

Site performance data in Site Audit.

SEO health encompasses all the technical factors that help search engines access and understand your site. This includes checking for broken pages, pages with few or no internal links, mobile experience issues, and other issues that might prevent your pages from ranking well.

Check your SEO health by opening Site Audit—the data is right at the top. Click on “Errors” to see which pages have major SEO issues and how to fix them. The tool also keeps an eye on your site on autopilot and can send you email updates.

Health Score in Site Audit.

SEO is where Ahrefs Webmaster Tools really shines, offering comprehensive backlink analysis, keyword tracking, and technical SEO auditing that goes far beyond what you can see in Google Search Console alone.

But you don’t need to choose. AWT integrates with Search Console so you can get Google’s data right inside Ahrefs.

GSC integration in AWT.
set up funnels in Ahrefs.

Funnels in Web Analytics.

Events capture all the micro-conversions that happen along the customer journey—email signups, download clicks, video plays, or any other action that indicates engagement. These smaller actions often predict larger conversions down the line.

Here’s a quick guide on how to set up events in Ahrefs.

Setting up events in Web Analytics.

AWT allows you to set up custom events and track funnel completions for the conversions that matter to your business. For more advanced conversion analysis, you might also consider Mixpanel or Hotjar.

Here’s a checklist to help you investigate.

In this example, I realized my article had just gone out of date. It was already 2025, but I was still recommending tools from 2023. After updating it, the traffic returned.

Acting on organic traffic decline.

Ongoing trends: the slow and steady signals

Gradual growth patterns are often more valuable than dramatic spikes because they indicate sustainable improvement. If your organic traffic increases by 10-15% each month for six consecutive months, that suggests your SEO strategy is working and your content is steadily gaining authority.

And here’s an example: the steady year-over-year growth of organic traffic and referring domains to ahrefs.com.

A pattern of steady organic traffic and referring domain growth.

Seasonal patterns reveal important timing opportunities. Many businesses see predictable fluctuations. Recognizing these patterns helps you prepare content calendars, adjust marketing budgets, and set realistic expectations for different times of year.

For example, Nerdwallet’s article on tax brackets shows a clear seasonal trend. No matter what they do, traffic to that page will always rise and fall at certain times of the year, because that’s simply when people are most likely to look for that information.

Seasonal organic traffic example.

Correlation spotting: finding the hidden connections

The most valuable insights often come from noticing how different metrics move together. When organic traffic increases alongside time on page and conversion rates, you’re likely creating content that attracts the right audience and serves them well.

Use an AI assistant like Claude or ChatGPT to help analyze and visualize your data. Just export the data from Web Analytics (top right corner) and ask the AI to look for patterns or connections. For example, here’s an analysis plan that Claude gave to me.

Claude AI helping with deeper web data analysis.

Red flags to watch for

Spotting these red flags early can save you from bigger issues down the line:

  • Steady drop in organic traffic could mean SEO trouble, stronger competition, or technical problems stopping search engines from indexing your site.
  • High bounce rates on key pages like your homepage or product pages suggest visitors aren’t finding what they expected, often due to slow load times or mismatched content.
  • Low conversion rates show that while people are visiting, they’re not taking action. This usually points to a poor user experience or unclear calls to action.
  • Slow load times (over 3 seconds) drive visitors away before your site even loads, which hurts both user experience and your rankings.
  • Relying too much on one traffic source (like Google or a single social platform) puts you at risk. One algorithm update or policy change can tank your traffic overnight.
our free tools, like the Website Traffic Checker.

Website Traffic Checker free tool.

To get a full picture, you’ll need more advanced data. Before we wrap up this article, let me give you a quick tour of the competitive data you can uncover with the Ahrefs Starter $29/mo plan.

Organic traffic comparison

How many visitors come to your site through unpaid search compared to competitors? This shows you the scale of opportunity in your market. If competitors get 50,000 monthly organic visitors while you get 5,000, that gap represents potential growth if you can improve your SEO strategy.

Share of voice measures your visibility in search results versus others in your space. This shows what percentage of total search visibility in your industry you’re capturing compared to competitors.

Traffic value reveals the monetary worth of your rankings. If you had to pay for your organic traffic through ads, what would it cost? A competitor with $10,000 worth of monthly organic traffic is capturing much more valuable search terms than one with $1,000 worth, even if their visitor numbers are similar.

You can uncover all this data in Site Explorer by plugging in your competitors’ domains and choosing the type of metric from this dropdown:

Performance data selector in Site Explorer.

And if you want to see which keywords generate traffic for your Competitors, simply open the Organic keywords report and see which ones would work for your website as well. 

Organic keywords report in Site Audit used for competitive analysis.

Brand recognition vs. content performance

Branded traffic shows how many people search specifically for your company name. It’s a strong sign of brand awareness and customer loyalty. If your competitors are seeing more branded searches, it likely means their brand is more recognized and in higher demand.

Unbranded traffic reveals content performance on competitive keywords. This is traffic from people searching for general topics, not brand names. High unbranded traffic means your content ranks well for broader, competitive search terms that anyone in your industry could target.

All of that data is available in Site Explorer’s Overview report.

Branded vs. non-branded competitive traffic analysis.

Geographic and audience insights

Where are your visitors located compared to competitors? Geographic analysis can reveal untapped markets. If competitors get significant traffic from regions where you have little presence, those areas might represent expansion opportunities.

All you need to do here is plug in your competitors’ domains in the Overview and click on the Compare top 5 on the chart, as shown below.

Competitors' traffic breakdown by location.

Backlink profile comparison

How many websites link to yours, and how does that compare to competitors? More importantly, what’s the quality difference? A competitor with 500 high-quality backlinks from respected industry sites will typically outperform one with 5,000 low-quality directory links.

Competitive backlink profile analysis.

To see where competitors get their backlinks, click on the Backlinks report.

Backlinks report in Site Explorer.

Paid search competitive intelligence

Top-level paid search analysis reveals which competitors are running ads, how much they’re likely spending, and how much traffic they’re getting from it. If they’re consistently investing in paid search, it’s a strong sign that it’s working for them, and worth considering in your own strategy.

Just open the Overview report in Site Explorer and click on the Paid search tab.

Paid search competitive data in Site Explorer.

Ad copy, keyword, and landing page insights reveal what messaging works for others in your space, helping you craft better campaigns and identify differentiation opportunities.

You can check all of the above in the Paid search reports.

Paid search reports in Site Explorer.

Further reading

LinkedIn. 

Similar Posts