Do Higher Content Scores Mean Higher Google Rankings? We Studied It (So You Don’t Have To)
Built within these scores is an implicit assumption that the higher your score, the higher you’ll likely rank on Google.
But is that actually true?
To find out, I studied the correlation between rankings and content scores from five content optimization tools: Surfer, Frase, NeuronWriter, Clearscope, and our own AI Content Helper.
We found weak correlations everywhere.
But out of the five tools I tested, NeuronWriter and AI Content Helper fared the best. The other three only had very weak correlations.
At first glance, these numbers may seem underwhelming. But ‘weak’ doesn’t mean ‘useless’.
Google uses hundreds of ranking signals to determine how pages rank. While correlation may not be causation, even a weak positive correlation means content scores can still move the needle.
Especially when it’s a factor you directly control.
Imagine if you had a button you could press that would give you a 10% chance of improving your rankings by one or two places. Would you press it?
I would spam the hell out of that button.
These tools are inexpensive, and you can use them to generate a positive impact on your rankings. It’s a massive, massive win for our industry.
AI Content Helper to focus on topic optimization. The goal is comprehensive content coverage—making sure you cover all the information your readers need to answer their questions.
Unlike other tools, you can’t ‘game’ our score by stuffing more keywords.
We think that this makes for better, more value-added content that’s more closely aligned with what both readers and Google want.
So far, so good. Not only did we score the highest in our correlation study, we also have examples of how we boosted our search traffic with our own tool:
2. Use relative scores as benchmarks
Don’t obsess over getting a perfect 100. Instead, use scores as a relative benchmark against top-ranking content.
If competing pages score in the 80-85 range while your page scores 79, it likely isn’t worth worrying about. But if it’s 95 vs. 20 then yeah, you should probably try to cover the topic better.
3. Balance optimization with originality
Content scores tell you how well you’re covering the topic based on what’s already out there. If you cover all important keywords and subtopics from the top-ranking pages and create the ultimate copycat content, you’ll score full marks.
This is a problem because quality content should bring something new to the table, not just rehash existing information. Google literally says this in their helpful content guidelines.
The most successful content strikes a balance between thorough topic coverage and original value.
So, while you’ll want to make something comprehensive and answer all your readers’ questions, make sure you’re also creating something that’ll stands out from the rest of the search results.
This will require experience, experimentation, or effort—something only humans can have/do.
4. Consider search intent first, scores second
Before diving into content optimization, make sure you understand what users actually want.
Content scores are most valuable when they’re guiding content that already matches the right search intent. That’s why the step after entering a keyword in AI Content Helper is for you to select the search intent you want to fulfill:
Final thoughts
Although the correlation between scores and rankings is weak, anything that you can control and impact your rankings is amazing news. Just don’t obsess and spend hours trying to get a perfect score; scoring in the same ballpark as top-ranking pages is enough.
You also need to be aware of their downsides, most notably that they can’t help you craft unique content. That requires human creativity and effort.
This Wednesday, May 8, I’m speaking at DrupalCon Portland 2024 as part of the Drupal Project Initiatives Keynote. The keynote is kicking off Contribution Day on Wednesday first thing in the morning. I’ll be highlighting initiatives and programs that are helping people contribute in a strategic way, and as a result, increasing throughput in the…
Semantic SEO sounds complicated, but it simply boils down to doing SEO without cutting corners. If you do SEO properly, you’re automatically doing semantic SEO. It’s just that most people aren’t doing it properly… It’s not a different type of SEO. You don’t need to do wildly different things. Rather, it’s a mental model that…
You’re looking for this article because you think long-form content works right? Or at least that’s what you’ve heard from many marketers. You might even have seen it for yourself. You’re trying to make a simple pasta dish (like aglio e olio) but you have to scroll through a piece that’s thousands of words long,…
Having a strong online presence is more important than ever. While social media platforms can give you a quick boost, blogging offers a more stable and in-depth approach to personal branding. So, how can you make use of blogging to build a personal brand? We will guide you through the steps that can help you…
I recently got this this question via the feedback form on the bottom of the Cache API Overview tutorial: “What is the difference between cache keys and cache tags? Why do I need a tag for node:5 when I can just invalidate it using a partial key like [‘node’, 5]?” After digging into the topic…
Get the week’s best marketing content As of 2024, the most searched thing on Google is “youtube.” The next most popular searched words are “amazon,” “facebook,” “gmail,” “wordle,“and “google.” Below are lists of the top 100 most popular searches and questions in the US and worldwide, pulled from our database of 28.7 billion keywords: Keywords…